Contractor Talk - Professional Construction and Remodeling Forum banner
41 - 60 of 116 Posts
I've cut lots of hundred plus year old
lumber that still has the same smell inside.
I guess I have cut some that smells musty. I didn't mean to say it always has a different smell, only a possibility.

What are we doing with this pile of stock Warner?
 
Looks like oak from here, too. I've been lucky enough to work with some of the old stuff, and it has a nice aroma, but nothing like the new oak...

Have you asked over at Woodworking Talk? Some of those guys are pretty keen.
 
You don't know our friend Darcy yet do you? :no::laughing::laughing:
No I don't. But I do like a man with nice tools. I have a few of the tools but the cases are dirty! My beer frig is much dirtier than his also. :laughing:
 
what about heart pine? seeing as your house is 'that' old the tight growth rings may fit the picture. If it's been gouged over the years (furniture, dog nails, etc...) consider it a softwood...so is it a softwood or hardwood?

Image
 
The little pores look oak like...

I would try to run a scew throught it, oak always splits on me if I try to screw it.

Then cut a few pieces and snort the saw dust and see how much it irritates your nostrels.:laughing:
 
41 - 60 of 116 Posts