Yeah...I'm on clip #3 right now. Love the case....hate the clip. Major league POS.Look at a lot of different cases and read a bunch of reviews, Otter Box Defender is probably the best tough case out there. I have a Crackberry Storm and have dropped it a few times and no problems what so ever. I would buy another one.
The Otter Box is a good mix of protection vs usability. If your case is not that old they will replace the clip. Otherwise they sell replacement cradles for about $15. Here is Otter's website: