Contractor Talk - Professional Construction and Remodeling Forum banner

Best and worst board brands

57K views 24 replies 14 participants last post by  intjonmiller  
#1 ·
What's your favorite? I prefer goldbond, I feel it gives the tightest joints, paper is always great, and makes for a beautiful finish. On the flip side I think Lafarge is freakin junk. Getting tight joints is a nightmare, the corners are rolled, paper is garbage. What's your opinions. I mostly hang 5/8" stand ups on metal
 
#7 ·
We have a USG plant, and 3 very good large suppliers within 13 miles of my home. We can get just about any product we want from the major brands. I really feel for the guys who have to depend on suppliers pushing out the defective board. Hard to make time when flats turn into butt joints all day long.
 
#13 ·
Must be why we don't have problems with the lightweight, we use USG mostly. We don't use lightweight 5/8 on the ceiling, but man I hate hanging that heavy stuff.
 
#20 ·
Our last basement we hung i specked out all gold bond high strength ceiling board.

It is about 27 pounds more than lite board but holds a screw perfect and cuts clean. Good screw holding is more important to us now that we run strictly collated. You can tell its density/strength when you carry its not making crackeling noises like lite board
 
#23 ·
I'm in Salt Lake. My employer buys from LW (locally called Building Specialists) and a local outfit called Swanson and they both carry the Pabco crap. Pabco is a regional brand made just outside Vegas. It has far more texture to the actual rock than any other brand I've used, including long fibers. It seems like that may add to its strength, which is nice, but it's terrible to cut. It doesn't snap, it slowly tears, especially if there's any humidity. And on this massive condo renovation job we're storing our materials in a vacant unit's garage, a few feet from the door so it is constantly exposed to the shifting weather/humidity this time of year. The long fibers are probably why it won't snap easily, and it's as itchy as any fiberglass I've ever encountered. And it leaves a rough edge that ALWAYS requires rasping, even when I score both sides before breaking it. Today I ordered a Blade Runner and a Tajima rasp, hoping that together it will make it a little less work. The biggest pieces I'm doing on this are about 6" strips around replacement entry doors and sidelights, along with little 2" sidelight window returns. I can't imagine needing to cut more often on a job than I am on this one, and they get me the worst boards in town.

For my own basement (45 boards) last week I ordered from LW and specifically said "Certainteed or USG". Half of the 4x8s were Pabco because "we were out of the others". Then tell me that and I'll order from someone else! I specified it for a reason! But I didn't know until after the delivery was complete.

I had also ordered three 16 foot boards. They brought me three 15 foot boards. "Oh, we don't stock 16s in Utah. We have to order those from California." THEN TELL ME AND I'LL ORDER FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE! With 15s I have a butt joint where it was supposed to be seamless! If I have to deal with a butt joint I'd rather two 8s than a 15 and a 1.

I will never order from them again.