Thank you.... Especially since in the middle of summer when that attic air may be as high 120 degrees or more.... and the R/A plenum or ductwork in said attic isn't sealed properly, you will be pulling much
warmer (a better choice of words?) return air back to the air handler than you would have if it were sealed properly.
Now granted, the good Doctor, may be more educated and able to pull links out the wazoo at my poor choice of words, but I was trained and worked for one of the most respected HVAC contractors in this city. He's now long since retired and has sold his business to his kids. But back then, he was the head of the Licensing board here in Indy, helped form, set up the ciriculam (sp?) for - and was on the board of (what at that time was) the only accredited trade school for HVAC technicians in town.
He was way ahead of his time in a lot of commercial refrigeration and HVAC solutions. Residentially, we were pushing duel fuel systems (heat pumps with gas back ups), long before they became fasionable and promoted by manufacturers today. We had mandatory monday evening training meetings once a month, where we would cover all kinds of topics related to all things HVAC. Some were commercial in nature, and I was strictly residential, but I was still required to attend. I'm sure, at some point we covered the very same topic about super heated air that the good Doctor brought up. But, I'm old now and don't remember.
But all of that doesn't mean squat. I understand that. I have not been through the intense and rigerous training of an HVAC technician. But I learned a lot from the man and together we solved a ton of airflow problems (mostly involving poor R/A situations) and improved the comfort of those we helped. He was very tough on me requiring every job I sold to be based on Manual J calculations with detailed drawings of the existing HVAC layout. He would question me about existing ductwork placement and would ask why I hadn't thought of doing this or that to improve the air balance in a particular part of the home.
He would get pretty upset with me if I missed something, so I learned quickly to look at everything and try to come up with solutions before he would even ask. It was constant back and forth Q&A debating solutions. When other companies would make a 30 minute sales call on a 100 degree day and try to sell a condensing unit only, I was required to do a detailed load calculation and drawing of the existing system layout and make recommendations on improving the entire system.
So, do I know everything? No, not at all. But, I do stand by what I said in my first post because we did many similar things moving air flow around in older homes to improve the balance and thus increasing comfort and efficiency for our customers.
I was a little over zealous in my second reply and shouldn't have been. I apologize to anyone I may have offended.