Bondo Or Wood Putty?

ecaryn

Please share your opinions and reasoning behind them on your choice of using Bondo (stuff used to repair car dings and dents) or regular wood putty to fill dents, holes, clean up plywood edges, etc on wood for finishing projects.

I know several carpenters and painters who swear by Bondo or the like for these applications. I've always stuck with wood putty but would be interested in knowing the benefits of the other. Thanks all.

OCRS

I've always used bondo for steel doors and frames and putty for wood. But if bondo holds up on something that flexes with temperature changes, vibration and being exposed to rain, maybe it's a better choice.

I think you'd have to be prepared for the differences in working time though.

Leo G

For anything that won't be getting wet (ie: exterior) I will use Bondo or putty. Usually if I have bigger holes to fill I will use bondo. If they are smaller (nail holes) I will Likely use putty. If I need it to be done quick, bondo. Putty has the chance to be stainable while bondo is a paint grade only option. If you need to do exterior puttying use glazing compound. You can paint it immediately and it will never shrink.

__________________
Sawdust Follows Me Everywhere

http://lrgwood.com
Custom Cabinets in Hartford County Connecticut

silvertree

Outside I reach for the Bondo. Interiors wood fillers. For speed and if its getting painted Bondo.
Plus I love the smell of Bondo in the morning

__________________
Vote for Pedro
Kitchen, bath, St Paul remodeling
Minneapolis Remodel Blog
203K Loan Consultant Minnesota

WarnerConstInc.

Epoxy.

Jason Whipple

Same here. Wood epxoy for wood, why do anything else?

Bondo is for steel and fiberglass, not wood.

__________________
Jason E Whipple, General Manager
Historic House Restoration, Cincinnati, Ohio
Facebook | Twitter

dlcj

Ive never tried bondo on a trim job but i have done and see it alot on custom speaker enclosures for car and home audio. They build the basic shape out of wood and use bondo and/or fiberglass to get the custom look they want. Then it is painted or covered with material. Speaker boxes especially subwoofer enclosures are very high in vibration and bondo holds in there very well.

pknyryan

Bondo is fine for inside or outside. I have worked at the 2 largest trim companies in Palm Beach, FL and the largest one in Greenwich, CT and they both use bondo. (all very high end outfits)

Bondo is good for a quick fix on paint grade, can be sanded and painted within an hour.

Epoxy is good too, especially for larger knots and holes on finish grade hardwoods.
MH Ready Patch works well too, for paint grade, but takes time to dry for bigger applications.

Putty is good for nailholes and small gaps in miters on finish wood.

They all have their place and should be on hand at all times if you are a trimmer.

orson

I'm not arguing that epoxy fillers are better, however, as far as bondo goes, what do you think Minwax 2 part wood filler is? It's bondo w/ a different color cream hardener.

__________________
Lancaster Remodeling Contractor - Lancaster Remodeling
Kitchen & Bath Remodeling PA- Bathroom Remodeling Lancaster PA
Custom Kitchen Remodeling PA - Ruby Construction FaceBook-Lancaster Bathroom Remodeling

nywoodwizard

Bondo is great for all kinds of uses metal or wood, i also used it outdoors on a few small rot holes in wood siding and its held up very well, its probably best for med size holes that are more easily workable, in the open. than as a nail filler,or tiny nicks
Repaired a piece of vintage molding missing a small chunk, didn't have time or resources to get a new piece, made it look like a new piece with bondo. Shapes fairly easy when first applied .Its a good filler.

__________________
Learning without thought is labor lost; thought without learning is perilous.

Quiglag

If you are good enough, it doesn't really matter what you use.

I was on a job installing a bank teller line. The manufacturer of the teller line had drilled a 2 1/2" hole in the wrong spot, very much visible to everyone. It was pre-finished mahogany colored alder, I think. The finisher came out, filled the hole with bondo, colored the bondo, and painted in wood grain. In the end, you could be 1' away and not see the hole.

RED HORSE 554

BONDO IS THE BEST PRODUCT UNLESS IT IS BEING STAINED IT WILL GIVE YOU BETTER SERVICE AND HOLDS UP FAR BETTER THAN ANY PUTTY.MOST PUTTYS ARE ONLY AS GOOD AS THE PAINT AND IF YOU LIVE IN A AREA THAT IS HEAVY WET TO DRY YOU WILL FACE EXPANDING AND CONTRACTING THAT WILL ALLOW THE PUTTY TO FAIL WHERE THE BONDO WILL HOLD UP IN THIS KIND OF CONDISHION.I USE BONDO INSIDE AS WELL IF IT IS BEING PAINTED IF STAINED THEN A PUTTY IS REQUIRED.I SAY BONDO IS THE BEST FOR LONG TERM SERVICE AND SHOULD BE USED.PUTTY IF YOU HAVE TO.

jmeg

Wood Putty is for homeowners and furniture restore!

Bondo(Minwax 2-part) is the best in my opinion. Although Epoxy sounds like a good idea, especially for outside. Setup and storage seems cumbersome though.

Stain grade work shouldn't need filler. Time spent filling, cleaning up, and sanding is usually far more than the three trips to the chopper.

Brock

No filler. Measure twice cut once. If your helper talks to you while you have 4 measurements in your head, slap him hard with your pimp hand then give him his final check.

RED HORSE 554

I agree brock but sometimes we must work behind others in doing repair and they may not have been at class that day and missed that set of instructions or recomendation

neolitic

Hmmm, how about all of those
shiny things in those holes?

__________________
Put your location in your profile!
(Sorry....it seems there really are dumb questions)

jmeg

Do you mean the putty itself, or nail heads? Both leave this shiny hole you speak of.
When a question about glue or hidden fastening arises I will be interested in hearing more from you.

Cdat

Glue and sawdust! Do it right the 1st time!

neolitic

I'm talking about filling nail holes
in pre-stained casing/base.

__________________
Put your location in your profile!
(Sorry....it seems there really are dumb questions)

miriolariu

If the cabinet will be painted, BONDO is your best route. Wood putty tends to crack when it dryes up, especially after a finish is applied.

If it's a stain grade product DO NOT USE BONDO, wood putty will have to do, i just hope it's not a big hole to be patched..in time it will crack.

I work with high end cabinets & we use both products daily.